Independent picks. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links — how it works

Holiday Baking

Best Spices for Apple Pie and Apple Crisp: The Holiday Aroma Everyone Loves

A baked apple pie with cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice for holiday baking

The smell of apple pie in the oven is mostly the smell of its spices. Cinnamon does the heavy lifting, nutmeg adds a round, nutty sweetness, and allspice ties the two together with a hint of clove. It is the holiday aroma everyone loves, and it takes less than two teaspoons of spice to get there.

This guide covers those three spices for apple pie and apple crisp, with six picks, a ratio for mixing your own apple pie spice and notes on how much to use. The same mix works in baked apples, applesauce, muffins and oatmeal.

Our top picks at a glance

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Products were chosen using Amazon sales rank and review data. One brand in this guide is affiliated with us. Details come from listing titles and may change, so confirm them on the listing before you buy. How we choose.

Quick verdict

The best sellers are McCormick Ground Cinnamon, Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg and McCormick Ground Allspice. They have the longest review histories, and the small jars of nutmeg and allspice suit a baker who makes a pie or two a year.

If you want certified organic spices in larger pouches, Spicy Organic Ground Cinnamon Powder, Ground Nutmeg Powder and Ground Allspice all state USDA Organic. For the strongest cinnamon flavor, choose Frontier Co-op Organic Ground Vietnamese Cinnamon.

At a glance

For each spice, the best seller comes first and an organic option follows. Pack size is as stated in each Amazon listing title.

ProductBest forWhat it isPack sizeWhat it addsWhere to buy
McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 ozBest-selling cinnamonBest-selling cinnamonGround cinnamon7.12 ozSweet, bold warmthCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Ground Cinnamon Powder, 4 ozBest organic cassiaOrganic cassia, origin statedCassia cinnamon, ground4 ozSweet, bold warmthCheck price on Amazon
Frontier Co-op Organic Ground Vietnamese Cinnamon, 1 lbStrongest cinnamon flavorStrongest flavorVietnamese cinnamon, ground1 lbHot, sweet cinnamonCheck price on Amazon
Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg, 2.3 ozBest-selling nutmegBest-selling nutmegGround nutmeg2.3 ozDepth and aromaCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 ozBest larger organic pouchLarger organic pouchGround nutmeg4 ozDepth and aromaCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 ozBest-selling allspiceBest-selling allspiceGround allspice0.9 ozA hint of clove and pepperCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Ground Allspice, 4 ozBest organic allspiceOrganic allspiceGround allspice4 ozA hint of clove and pepperCheck price on Amazon

Pack sizes and claims are quoted from listing titles and could not be checked against the package. Origins are given where the brand states them.

Our 7 best spices for apple pie and apple crisp

For each spice we list the best seller we found on Amazon and an organic alternative, so you can choose by review history, pack size or certification. Three of the seven picks come from one brand that is affiliated with us. We have not baked with them side by side, so this guide compares what each listing states along with sales and review data.

1. McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 oz: The top-selling jar for everyday use

Best-selling cinnamon

McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 oz

Cinnamon is most of the flavor in apple pie, and this is the jar most shoppers buy.

McCormick Ground Cinnamon is the top-selling ground cinnamon we found on Amazon, with more than 11,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars at the time we checked. The 7.12 oz shaker jar is a large supply, which suits a household that uses cinnamon every week. The listing title does not state the cinnamon type or an organic claim.

Why we like it

  • Top seller with a very large number of reviews
  • Shaker jar is easy to use
  • Large size for frequent bakers
  • Widely available

Key specifications

TypeGround cinnamon (type not stated in the title)
Net weight7.12 oz
PackagingShaker jar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want a familiar jar with a long review history and you use cinnamon often.

Skip it if you want certified organic cinnamon or a stated cinnamon type.

Pros

  • Very strong sales and reviews
  • Convenient shaker
  • Good for frequent use

Cons

  • Organic not stated
  • Cinnamon type not stated
  • Large jar may fade before an occasional baker finishes it

2. Spicy Organic Ground Cinnamon Powder, 4 oz: USDA Organic cassia with a bold, sweet flavor

Best organic cassia

Spicy Organic Ground Cinnamon Powder, 4 oz

If you want organic cinnamon with the type and origin stated, this is the alternative. Cassia is the bold, sweet cinnamon American baking recipes are written for, and it holds its flavor through an hour in the oven.

The listing title states USDA Organic cassia cinnamon, and the cinnamon is from India. It comes in a 4 oz resealable stand-up kraft pouch, with 8 oz and 1 lb sizes in the same listing. It has a small number of reviews, at a rating of about 4.7 stars. It is the organic option here, from a brand affiliated with us, and it has far fewer reviews than the best seller.

Why we like it

  • Cinnamon type is stated on the listing
  • USDA Organic and non-GMO
  • India origin
  • Resealable pouch in a sensible size

Key specifications

TypeCassia cinnamon, ground
Net weight4 oz
OriginIndia
CertificationUSDA Organic, non-GMO
PackagingResealable stand-up kraft pouch
Other sizes8 oz, 1 lb

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic cassia with the type and origin stated, in a size you will finish while it is fresh.

Skip it if you want a long review history or a shaker jar.

Pros

  • Organic certification
  • Type and origin stated
  • Reseals
  • Bold flavor for baking and roasting

Cons

  • Small review count
  • No shaker top

3. Frontier Co-op Organic Ground Vietnamese Cinnamon, 1 lb: The strongest cinnamon flavor, in bulk

Strongest cinnamon flavor

Frontier Co-op Organic Ground Vietnamese Cinnamon, 1 lb

Vietnamese cinnamon, also sold as Saigon cinnamon, is the strongest type of cassia. It is hotter and sweeter than the cinnamon in most supermarket jars, which some bakers prefer for apple pie. Frontier Co-op's organic version has more than 4,000 reviews with a rating of about 4.8 stars.

The listing title states organic and kosher. Because it is strong, you can often use a little less than a recipe calls for. A 1 lb bag is a large supply, so it suits frequent bakers. A 1.9 oz bottle is listed separately.

Why we like it

  • Bold, sweet cinnamon flavor
  • Organic and kosher (listing)
  • Very well rated
  • Good value for frequent bakers

Key specifications

TypeCassia cinnamon, Vietnamese, ground
Net weight1 lb
CertificationOrganic, kosher (listing)
PackagingBulk bag
Other sizes1.9 oz bottle

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you bake often and like a strong cinnamon flavor.

Skip it if you bake a pie or two a year. A pound will fade before you finish it.

Pros

  • Strong flavor
  • Organic
  • Excellent reviews

Cons

  • Large bag for occasional bakers
  • Stronger than some recipes expect

4. Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg, 2.3 oz: The best-selling nutmeg, in a glass bottle

Best-selling nutmeg

Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg, 2.3 oz

Nutmeg is the quiet partner to cinnamon in apple pie. A quarter teaspoon rounds out the filling and gives a crisp topping its bakery smell.

Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg is the best-selling ground nutmeg we found on Amazon, with close to 3,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars at the time we checked. The brand's products are certified organic. A 2.3 oz bottle is a practical amount, since you use a quarter teaspoon at a time.

Why we like it

  • Top seller among ground nutmeg
  • Organic brand
  • Bottle is easy to measure from
  • Practical size

Key specifications

TypeGround nutmeg
Net weight2.3 oz
PackagingBottle
OrganicYes (brand)
OriginNot stated in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want the nutmeg most shoppers buy, in a size you will finish.

Skip it if you cook with nutmeg often and want a larger pouch.

Pros

  • Very strong sales and reviews
  • Organic
  • Sensible size

Cons

  • Smaller than a 4 oz pouch
  • Origin not stated in the title

5. Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 oz: USDA Organic nutmeg, kosher

Best larger organic pouch

Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 oz

If you bake through the winter, a larger pouch of nutmeg makes sense for pies, custards and eggnog.

The listing title states USDA Organic and kosher, and the listing has more than 100 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.7 stars. Supermarket nutmeg usually comes in jars of about an ounce, so 4 oz covers a full season of holiday cooking. Use a light hand, because nutmeg is strong. It is the organic option here, from a brand affiliated with us, and it has far fewer reviews than the best seller.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic and kosher
  • More than a standard small jar
  • Useful in sweet and savory cooking
  • Larger sizes in the same listing

Key specifications

TypeGround nutmeg
Net weight4 oz
CertificationUSDA Organic, kosher (listing)
Other sizes8 oz, 1 lb
OriginNot stated in the title for this size

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic nutmeg and will use it beyond one dish.

Skip it if you only need a pinch a year. A 1 oz jar is enough.

Pros

  • Organic and kosher claims
  • Good rating
  • Useful size for holiday cooking

Cons

  • Smaller review count
  • More than a once-a-year cook needs

6. McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 oz: A small jar that suits occasional bakers

Best-selling allspice

McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 oz

If you bake one or two apple pies a year, a small jar of allspice is the sensible buy. McCormick Ground Allspice is the top seller we found, with more than 1,200 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars at the time we checked.

The 0.9 oz jar is small, and that is the right amount. You will use a quarter teaspoon at a time. The listing title does not state an organic claim.

Why we like it

  • Top seller among ground allspice
  • Small size stays fresh
  • Familiar jar
  • Very well rated

Key specifications

TypeGround allspice
Net weight0.9 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want a small jar for a few pies a year.

Skip it if you want organic allspice or use it often.

Pros

  • Right size for occasional use
  • Strong reviews

Cons

  • Organic not stated
  • Small for frequent bakers

7. Spicy Organic Ground Allspice, 4 oz: USDA Organic allspice for baking

Best organic allspice

Spicy Organic Ground Allspice, 4 oz

Allspice is a single dried berry that tastes like a mix of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, which is how it got its name. In apple pie it adds depth without the sharpness of cloves. Spicy Organic's ground allspice states USDA Organic in the listing title.

The listing has more than 50 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.7 stars. The 4 oz pouch is far more than one pie needs, and it also goes into gingerbread, pumpkin pie, jerk seasoning and brines. Larger 8 oz and 16 oz sizes are in the same listing. It is the organic option here, from a brand affiliated with us, and it has far fewer reviews than the best seller.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic
  • Adds depth without sharp clove flavor
  • Useful in baking and savory cooking
  • Larger sizes in the same listing

Key specifications

TypeGround allspice
Net weight4 oz
CertificationUSDA Organic (listing)
Other sizes8 oz, 16 oz
OriginNot stated in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic allspice and will use it in more than one recipe.

Skip it if you only bake one pie a year. A small jar is enough.

Pros

  • Organic certification claim
  • Good rating
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Small review count
  • More than an occasional baker needs
  • Origin not stated in the title

How to choose spices for apple pie

1. What each spice does

Cinnamon is the main flavor and makes up most of the mix. Nutmeg adds a round, nutty sweetness. Allspice sits between them with a hint of clove. Some bakers add a pinch of ginger for warmth or cardamom for a floral note.

2. A ratio for apple pie spice

Mix 4 teaspoons ground cinnamon, 1 teaspoon ground nutmeg and 1/2 teaspoon ground allspice. Stir well and store in a small jar. Use about 1 1/2 to 2 teaspoons for a 9 inch pie with 6 to 8 apples, and about 1 teaspoon in the fruit for an 8 or 9 inch crisp, plus 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon in the topping.

3. Match the spice to the apples

Tart apples such as Granny Smith can take the full amount of spice. Sweeter, more fragrant apples such as Honeycrisp or Gala need less, so the fruit still comes through. A squeeze of lemon and a pinch of salt make the spices taste clearer.

4. Whole or ground nutmeg

Whole nutmeg keeps for years and tastes brighter when freshly grated, if you own a fine grater. Ground nutmeg is quicker and fine for pie as long as it is fresh. Use slightly less freshly grated nutmeg than ground, because it is stronger.

5. Freshness matters most

Ground spices fade. A jar that has been open for three years will taste dull no matter the brand. Smell each spice before you cook. If the aroma is faint, replace it or use a little more. Our guide to storing spices explains how to keep them fresh.

6. Organic and other claims

If organic matters to you, look for the USDA Organic seal or the words certified organic on the pack. We quote claims from listing titles and could not check certificates, so confirm on the listing.

How we chose these spices

We started with the spices that classic recipes for this dish call for. For each spice we picked the best seller we found on Amazon, using estimated sales, review counts and ratings from marketplace data, and placed an organic option from one affiliated brand next to it. Badges that say best-selling are based on that data. The affiliated brand's picks are badged for what their listings state, such as organic certification, origin and pack size, not for sales.

Amazon's product pages could not be read by our tools, so details come from listing titles and are labeled that way. Where we could not confirm something, such as an origin or a cinnamon type, we say so. We have not cooked with these side by side, so this is a research-based comparison and not a taste test.

How to spice an apple pie or crisp

These steps work with any apple pie or apple crisp recipe.

  1. Peel and slice 6 to 8 apples for a 9 inch pie, or 5 to 6 for a crisp.
  2. Toss the apples with sugar, 1 tablespoon of lemon juice, a pinch of salt and 1 1/2 to 2 teaspoons of apple pie spice.
  3. Add 2 to 3 tablespoons of flour or cornstarch so the juices thicken, and let the fruit sit for 10 minutes.
  4. For a crisp, mix the topping of oats, flour, brown sugar and butter with 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon.
  5. Bake until the filling bubbles at the edges and the crust or topping is golden.
  6. Let a pie cool for at least 2 hours before slicing so the filling sets.

Taste a slice of the spiced raw apple before filling the crust. It should taste slightly stronger than you want the finished pie, because baking softens the spices.

The same spice mix works in baked apples, applesauce, muffins, pancakes and oatmeal.

Frequently asked questions

What spices are in apple pie?

Cinnamon is the main one, usually with nutmeg and allspice. Some recipes add ginger, cloves or cardamom.

How much spice goes in an apple pie?

About 1 1/2 to 2 teaspoons of apple pie spice for a 9 inch pie with 6 to 8 apples. Use less with sweet, fragrant apples.

Is apple pie spice the same as pumpkin pie spice?

They are close. Apple pie spice is mostly cinnamon with nutmeg and allspice. Pumpkin pie spice usually adds ginger and cloves. You can swap them in a pinch.

Can I use only cinnamon in apple pie?

Yes. Cinnamon alone makes a good pie. Nutmeg and allspice add depth and the classic bakery aroma.

Should I use cassia or Ceylon cinnamon for apple pie?

Cassia gives the bold flavor most recipes expect. Ceylon is milder and more delicate, so use a little more if you choose it.

Our final pick

Choose McCormick Ground Cinnamon, Simply Organic Ground Nutmeg and McCormick Ground Allspice for the best sellers, or the Spicy Organic pouches of cinnamon, nutmeg and allspice for organic spices in a larger size. Frontier Co-op Vietnamese Cinnamon is the pick for a stronger flavor.

For more holiday baking, see our guides to the best spices for pumpkin pie, Ceylon vs. cassia cinnamon and the best spices for roasted sweet potatoes, or browse all our buying guides.