Independent picks. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links — how it works

Thanksgiving

Best Herbs and Spices for Thanksgiving Turkey: 7 Top Picks for Rubs, Stuffing and Gravy

A roast turkey with fresh sage, rosemary and thyme and small bowls of pepper, paprika, garlic and dried herbs on a wooden table

A turkey is a big, mild bird, and most of its flavor comes from what you put on it. The classic Thanksgiving taste is a short list of dried herbs and spices: sage, thyme and rosemary, backed by garlic, black pepper and salt. The same handful seasons the stuffing and the gravy, which is why the whole meal tastes like it belongs together.

You can buy those flavors already mixed as poultry seasoning, or buy the herbs one by one and build your own rub. This guide covers both, with seven top-selling picks, a simple dry rub ratio and a note on how much seasoning a turkey needs.

Our top picks at a glance

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Products were chosen using Amazon sales rank and review data. One brand in this guide is affiliated with us. Details come from listing titles and may change, so confirm them on the listing before you buy. How we choose.

Quick verdict

For the easiest route, buy a jar of poultry seasoning. McCormick Gourmet Organic Poultry Seasoning is the best-selling blend we found, and Frontier Co-op Organic Poultry Seasoning is the highest rated. One jar seasons the bird, the stuffing and the gravy.

To build your own rub, start with McCormick Rubbed Sage, McCormick Thyme Leaves and Badia Rosemary Leaves, then add Spicy Organic Granulated Garlic and McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper. Those five, plus salt, cover everything on the table.

At a glance

Two blends first, then the single herbs and spices. Pack size is as stated in each Amazon listing title.

ProductBest forWhat it isPack sizeUse it forWhere to buy
McCormick Gourmet Organic Poultry Seasoning, 0.87 ozBest ready-made blendEasiest optionOrganic blend0.87 ozTurkey, stuffing, gravyCheck price on Amazon
Frontier Co-op Organic Poultry Seasoning, 1.2 ozHighest-rated blendHighest-rated blendOrganic blend1.2 ozTurkey, stuffing, gravyCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Rubbed Sage, 0.5 ozBest sageThe Thanksgiving herbRubbed sage0.5 ozStuffing and rubsCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Thyme Leaves, 0.75 ozBest thymeGravy and rubsThyme leaves0.75 ozGravy, rubs, vegetablesCheck price on Amazon
Badia Rosemary Leaves, 1 ozBest rosemaryPiney, roasted flavorRosemary leaves1 ozRubs and roast potatoesCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Granulated Garlic, 4 ozBest garlicSavory depthGranulated garlic4 ozRubs, butter, gravyCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper, 3 ozBest black pepperEveryday seasoningGround black pepper3 ozEverythingCheck price on Amazon

Pack sizes and claims are quoted from listing titles and could not be checked against the package. Blend ingredients vary by brand, so check the label.

Our 7 best herbs and spices for turkey

The first two picks are ready-made blends and the other five are single herbs and spices. Each is a top seller or a well-rated option in its category. We have not cooked with them side by side, so this guide compares what each listing states along with sales and review data.

1. McCormick Gourmet Organic Poultry Seasoning, 0.87 oz: The best-selling blend for turkey

Best ready-made blend

McCormick Gourmet Organic Poultry Seasoning, 0.87 oz

Poultry seasoning is the shortcut to a classic turkey. McCormick Gourmet's organic version was the best-selling poultry seasoning we found on Amazon, with more than 2,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.6 stars at the time we checked. The listing title describes it as a blend of thyme, sage and other spices and states organic, non-GMO and kosher.

The 0.87 oz jar is enough for a turkey, a pan of stuffing and a batch of gravy, with some left for roast chicken through the winter.

Why we like it

  • Top seller among poultry seasonings
  • States organic, non-GMO and kosher
  • One jar seasons the whole meal
  • Small size stays fresh

Key specifications

TypePoultry seasoning blend
Net weight0.87 oz
Main herbsThyme, sage and other spices (listing)
ClaimsOrganic, non-GMO, kosher (listing)
SaltNot stated in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want one jar that gives the turkey, stuffing and gravy a matching flavor.

Skip it if you like to control how much sage or rosemary goes in.

Pros

  • Simple
  • Balanced classic flavor
  • Organic claim
  • Strong seller

Cons

  • Fixed balance of herbs
  • Small jar for a very large bird and stuffing
  • Full ingredient list not in the title

2. Frontier Co-op Organic Poultry Seasoning, 1.2 oz: A slightly larger organic blend with a top rating

Highest-rated blend

Frontier Co-op Organic Poultry Seasoning, 1.2 oz

Frontier Co-op's organic poultry seasoning has more than 1,700 reviews with a rating of about 4.8 stars, the highest of the blends we looked at. The listing title states organic.

At 1.2 oz it holds a little more than the McCormick jar, which helps if you are seasoning a large turkey and a big pan of stuffing.

Why we like it

  • Highest rating among the blends
  • Organic claim
  • A bit more in the jar
  • From a co-op spice brand

Key specifications

TypePoultry seasoning blend
Net weight1.2 oz
OrganicYes (listing)
IngredientsNot listed in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want an organic blend and are cooking for a crowd.

Skip it if you want to know the exact herbs before buying. Check the listing's ingredient panel.

Pros

  • Very high rating
  • Organic
  • Good amount

Cons

  • Ingredients not in the title
  • Fixed balance of herbs

3. McCormick Rubbed Sage, 0.5 oz: The herb that makes stuffing taste like stuffing

Best sage

McCormick Rubbed Sage, 0.5 oz

Sage is the signature flavor of Thanksgiving. Rubbed sage is dried sage leaves gently rubbed into a light, fluffy powder that blends easily into stuffing, rubs and sausage. McCormick's is the top-selling rubbed sage we found, with about 1,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.7 stars.

Half an ounce sounds small, but rubbed sage is very light, so the jar holds plenty for the holiday. Sage is strong, and a little goes a long way.

Why we like it

  • Top-selling rubbed sage
  • Fluffy texture blends evenly
  • Right amount for holiday cooking
  • Strong, classic aroma

Key specifications

TypeRubbed sage
Net weight0.5 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you make stuffing or dressing from scratch, or mix your own turkey rub.

Skip it if you only use a poultry seasoning blend, which already contains sage.

Pros

  • Essential Thanksgiving flavor
  • Easy to blend
  • Well rated

Cons

  • Not labeled organic
  • Easy to overdo

4. McCormick Thyme Leaves, 0.75 oz: The quiet herb behind good gravy

Best thyme

McCormick Thyme Leaves, 0.75 oz

Thyme is earthy and slightly lemony, and it ties sage and rosemary together. It is the herb most cooks reach for in gravy and in the butter that goes under the turkey skin. McCormick Thyme Leaves has more than 1,400 reviews with a rating of about 4.8 stars.

The 0.75 oz jar is a sensible size for home cooking. If you use thyme all year, larger containers are available as separate listings.

Why we like it

  • Very high rating
  • Whole dried leaves hold flavor better than ground
  • Useful in gravy, rubs and roast vegetables
  • Sensible jar size

Key specifications

TypeDried thyme leaves
Net weight0.75 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you make gravy from drippings or season the bird with herb butter.

Skip it if you cook with thyme every week. A bigger container costs less per ounce.

Pros

  • Versatile
  • Well rated
  • Leaf form

Cons

  • Not labeled organic
  • Small for heavy users

5. Badia Rosemary Leaves, 1 oz: Piney aroma for the bird and the potatoes

Best rosemary

Badia Rosemary Leaves, 1 oz

Rosemary adds a piney, resinous note that suits roasted poultry and potatoes. Badia's dried rosemary leaves have more than 2,200 reviews across sizes with a rating of about 4.8 stars.

Dried rosemary leaves are firm, almost like small needles. Crush them between your fingers or chop them before adding to a rub so they soften as the turkey roasts. An 8 oz size is in the same brand's range if you use a lot.

Why we like it

  • Very high rating with a large review base
  • 1 oz covers the holiday meal
  • Works on turkey, potatoes and bread
  • Larger size available

Key specifications

TypeDried rosemary leaves
Net weight1 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you like a bold, roasted-herb flavor on the turkey and the sides.

Skip it if you find rosemary too strong. Use more thyme instead.

Pros

  • Strong aroma
  • Well rated
  • Good value

Cons

  • Leaves need crushing
  • Not labeled organic

6. Spicy Organic Granulated Garlic, 4 oz: USDA Organic garlic that will not burn like fresh

Best garlic

Spicy Organic Granulated Garlic, 4 oz

Granulated garlic is dried garlic ground to a coarse, sandy texture. It spreads evenly in a dry rub and does not scorch the way minced fresh garlic can during a long roast. Spicy Organic's states USDA Organic in the listing title and has about 250 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.4 stars.

The 4 oz pouch is enough for the turkey, the mashed potatoes and garlic bread, with plenty left for everyday cooking. An 8 oz size is in the same listing.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic
  • Coarse grind blends well into rubs
  • Holds up through long roasting
  • Useful all year

Key specifications

TypeGranulated garlic
Net weight4 oz
CertificationUSDA Organic (listing)
Other sizes8 oz
OriginNot stated in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic garlic for rubs, compound butter and gravy.

Skip it if you prefer fine garlic powder, or you only cook with fresh garlic.

Pros

  • Organic certification claim
  • Even coverage in rubs
  • Sensible size

Cons

  • Rated a little lower than the other picks
  • Fewer reviews than the biggest garlic sellers

7. McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper, 3 oz: The seasoning every dish on the table needs

Best black pepper

McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper, 3 oz

Black pepper goes into the rub, the gravy, the mashed potatoes and the green beans. McCormick Pure Ground Black Pepper is the top seller we found, with more than 17,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars.

The 3 oz tin is the familiar pantry size. If you prefer the brighter flavor of freshly cracked pepper, a grinder with whole peppercorns is a good second option for the table.

Why we like it

  • Top seller with a very large review base
  • Fine grind blends into rubs and gravy
  • Pantry staple size
  • Consistent flavor

Key specifications

TypeGround black pepper
Net weight3 oz
PackagingTin
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you need a dependable ground pepper for cooking the whole meal.

Skip it if you grind your own peppercorns.

Pros

  • Trusted staple
  • Thousands of reviews
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Pre-ground pepper is milder than fresh
  • Not labeled organic

How to season a Thanksgiving turkey

1. Blend or single herbs

Poultry seasoning is a ready-made mix, usually sage, thyme, marjoram, rosemary, pepper and sometimes nutmeg. It is the simplest way to get the classic flavor. Buying the herbs separately lets you lean toward the ones you like, for example more thyme and less sage, and you will use them in other cooking.

2. A simple dry rub

For a 12 to 14 lb turkey, a good starting point is 1 tablespoon kosher salt, 2 teaspoons rubbed sage, 2 teaspoons thyme, 1 teaspoon crushed rosemary, 2 teaspoons granulated garlic and 1 teaspoon black pepper. Mix it into softened butter or oil and spread it over and under the skin. Scale it up for a larger bird.

3. How much to use

If you are using poultry seasoning, 1 to 2 tablespoons for the bird is typical, plus 1 to 2 teaspoons in the stuffing and a pinch in the gravy. Check whether your blend contains salt before adding more. Most do not, but some do.

4. Dried or fresh herbs

Dried herbs are stronger by volume than fresh. As a rule, use about one third as much dried as fresh. Dried herbs are better in rubs and long cooking, and fresh herbs are nicer tucked into the cavity or scattered at the end.

5. Check freshness before the big day

Dried herbs lose their aroma after a year or two. Rub a pinch between your fingers. If you can barely smell it, replace the jar, because old sage and thyme will make a flat stuffing no matter how much you add.

6. Season early

Seasoning the turkey the day before and leaving it uncovered in the fridge gives the salt time to work and dries the skin so it browns better. If you are short on time, season at least an hour ahead. For storage tips, see our guide to storing spices.

How we chose these herbs and spices

We started with the herbs and spices that classic roast turkey, stuffing and gravy recipes call for, then looked at Amazon's best sellers in each one using estimated sales, review counts and ratings from marketplace data. We chose pack sizes that suit a holiday meal, which means we sometimes picked a small jar over the single biggest seller.

Amazon's product pages could not be read by our tools, so details come from listing titles and are labeled that way. Where we could not confirm something, such as a blend's full ingredients, we say so. We have not cooked with these side by side, so this is a research-based comparison and not a taste test.

How to season the turkey, step by step

This works with a blend or with your own mix of herbs.

  1. Pat the thawed turkey dry with paper towels, inside and out.
  2. Mix your herbs and spices with salt, then stir them into softened butter or oil.
  3. Loosen the skin over the breast with your fingers and spread some of the mixture underneath. Rub the rest over the outside.
  4. Season the cavity with a little more of the mix, and add onion, lemon or fresh herbs if you like.
  5. Roast at 325°F or higher until a thermometer reads 165°F in the thigh, wing and thickest part of the breast, then rest the bird before carving.

Use the same herbs in the stuffing and gravy so the meal tastes consistent.

For the tools, see our guides to the best turkey roasting pans and best meat thermometers.

Frequently asked questions

What herbs and spices go on a Thanksgiving turkey?

Sage, thyme and rosemary are the classic herbs, with garlic, black pepper and salt. Poultry seasoning combines most of them in one jar.

What is poultry seasoning made of?

Usually sage, thyme, marjoram, rosemary and black pepper, sometimes with nutmeg. The mix varies by brand, so check the label.

How much poultry seasoning do I need for a turkey?

About 1 to 2 tablespoons for a 12 to 14 lb bird, plus a teaspoon or two for the stuffing and a pinch for the gravy.

Should I use fresh or dried herbs?

Dried herbs work best in rubs and long roasting. Fresh herbs are good in the cavity and as a garnish. Use about one third as much dried as fresh.

Is granulated garlic the same as garlic powder?

They are both dried garlic. Granulated garlic is coarser, so it blends evenly in rubs and is less likely to clump. Garlic powder is finer and dissolves faster.

When should I season the turkey?

The day before is best, left uncovered in the fridge. If that is not possible, season at least an hour before roasting.

Can I use the same seasoning for stuffing and gravy?

Yes. Using the same herbs across the bird, stuffing and gravy is what makes the meal taste like one dish.

Our final pick

For the simplest turkey, buy McCormick Gourmet Organic Poultry Seasoning or the highly rated Frontier Co-op blend. To make your own rub, combine McCormick Rubbed Sage, McCormick Thyme Leaves, Badia Rosemary, Spicy Organic Granulated Garlic and McCormick Black Pepper with salt.

Finishing your Thanksgiving plan? See our guides to the best turkey roasting pans, best turkey carving knives and best spices for pumpkin pie, and the rest of our buying guides.