Independent picks. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links — how it works

Holiday Drinks

Best Mulling Spices for Cider and Wine: 7 Top Picks, Blends and Whole Spices

A bowl of whole mulling spices with cinnamon sticks, star anise and orange peel beside a mug of hot cider and a glass of mulled wine

A pot of mulled cider on the stove makes the whole house smell like the holidays. Mulling simply means gently heating a drink with whole spices so their flavor steeps into it. The drink can be apple cider, red wine, cranberry juice or even tea, and the spices are almost always the same: cinnamon sticks, whole cloves, allspice berries and star anise, often with orange peel.

You can buy mulling spices ready to use, or keep the whole spices on hand and mix your own. This guide covers both, with seven top-selling picks, a simple ratio for a gallon of cider and tips for keeping the drink clear and not bitter.

Our top picks at a glance

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Products were chosen using Amazon sales rank and review data. One brand in this guide is affiliated with us. Details come from listing titles and may change, so confirm them on the listing before you buy. How we choose.

Quick verdict

For the least effort, choose a ready-made option. Aspen Mulling Cider Spices is the best-selling mulling mix we found, and Olde Tradition Mulling Spices in Tea Bags keeps the spices contained, so there is nothing to strain.

To mull from scratch, you need four whole spices: McCormick Whole Cinnamon Sticks, Spicy Organic Whole Cloves, The Spice Way Star Anise and Spicy World Whole Allspice Berries. Add a few HANDPICK Green Cardamom Pods if you like a brighter, more fragrant cup.

At a glance

Two ready-made options first, then the whole spices. Pack size is as stated in each Amazon listing title.

ProductBest forWhat it isPack sizeRole in the potWhere to buy
Aspen Mulling Cider Spices Original Blend, 5.65 ozBest ready-made mixEasiest optionMulling spice mix5.65 ozStir-in flavorCheck price on Amazon
Olde Tradition Spice Mulling Spices in Tea Bags, 24 CountBest no-mess optionNo strainingSpices in tea bags24 bagsSteep and removeCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Whole Cinnamon Sticks, 8 ozBest cinnamon sticksThe base spiceCinnamon sticks8 ozSweet, warm backboneCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Whole Cloves, 4 ozBest clovesDeep, sharp warmthWhole cloves4 ozStrong accentCheck price on Amazon
The Spice Way Star Anise, 3 ozBest star aniseFlavor and looksWhole star anise3 ozLight licorice noteCheck price on Amazon
Spicy World Whole Allspice Berries, 2 ozBest allspiceRounding out the blendWhole allspice berries2 ozPeppery warmthCheck price on Amazon
HANDPICK Green Cardamom Pods, 2 ozBest optional extraA fragrant extraGreen cardamom pods2 ozBright, floral liftCheck price on Amazon

Pack sizes and claims are quoted from listing titles and could not be checked against the package. Ready-made mixes vary in what they contain, so check the label for ingredients such as sugar.

Our 7 best mulling spices

The first two picks are ready to use and the other five are whole spices for mixing your own. Each is a top seller or a well-rated option in its category. We have not tasted them side by side, so this guide compares what each listing states along with sales and review data.

1. Aspen Mulling Cider Spices Original Blend, 5.65 oz: The best-known mulling mix

Best ready-made mix

Aspen Mulling Cider Spices Original Blend, 5.65 oz

Aspen Mulling Spices is the mulling product most shoppers buy. The original blend lists cinnamon, nutmeg and clove in its title and is described as a mix for spiced cider, mulled red wine and other winter drinks. This single carton has more than 1,600 reviews with a rating of about 4.6 stars, and multi-packs of the same blend sell even more.

It is the choice for a quick mug or a last-minute pot when you do not want to measure whole spices. Check the ingredient panel on the listing if you want to know whether it contains sugar.

Why we like it

  • Best-selling mulling product we found
  • Works for cider, wine and other drinks
  • No measuring of separate spices
  • Multi-packs available for gifting

Key specifications

TypeMulling spice mix
Net weight5.65 oz
FlavorsCinnamon, nutmeg, clove (listing)
UseCider, red wine, other hot drinks (listing)
IngredientsFull list not in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want mulled cider with the least effort, by the mug or by the pot.

Skip it if you want to control sweetness and spice strength yourself.

Pros

  • Fast and easy
  • Widely loved
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Fixed flavor
  • Ingredients not listed in the title
  • Less aromatic than simmering whole spices

2. Olde Tradition Spice Mulling Spices in Tea Bags, 24 Count: Steep, lift out, done

Best no-mess option

Olde Tradition Spice Mulling Spices in Tea Bags, 24 Count

Olde Tradition packs its mulling spices into tea bags. You drop a bag into a mug or a few into a pot, steep, and lift them out, with no straining and no stray cloves in anyone's cup. It has more than 2,300 reviews with a rating of about 4.5 stars.

The 24 count box is handy for parties, slow cookers and gifts. An 8 count box is available as a separate listing if you want to try it first.

Why we like it

  • Nothing to strain
  • Easy to scale from one mug to a full pot
  • Good for slow cookers and parties
  • Smaller box available

Key specifications

TypeMulling spices in tea bags
Quantity24 bags
UseCider, wine, tea
IngredientsNot listed in the title

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want real spices without the cleanup, or you are serving a crowd.

Skip it if you enjoy the look of whole spices floating in the pot.

Pros

  • Tidy
  • Flexible portions
  • Well reviewed

Cons

  • Rated slightly lower than other picks
  • Ingredients not listed in the title

3. McCormick Whole Cinnamon Sticks, 8 oz: The backbone of every mulled drink

Best cinnamon sticks

McCormick Whole Cinnamon Sticks, 8 oz

Cinnamon sticks do most of the work in a mulled drink. They release flavor slowly, so the drink turns warm and sweet without going cloudy the way ground cinnamon would. McCormick's whole sticks are the top-selling cinnamon sticks we found, with more than 7,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.7 stars.

Eight ounces is a generous supply. It will cover several large pots of cider and still leave sticks for stirring hot chocolate, flavoring rice and decorating. For the difference between cinnamon types, see our Ceylon vs. cassia guide.

Why we like it

  • Top seller with a large review base
  • Whole sticks keep drinks clear
  • Big enough for the whole season
  • Doubles as a garnish

Key specifications

TypeWhole cinnamon sticks
Net weight8 oz
Cinnamon typeNot stated in the title
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you plan to mull more than once this season, or you entertain.

Skip it if you only want a few sticks for one pot. A smaller pack is enough.

Pros

  • Strong, sweet flavor
  • Long shelf life
  • Many uses

Cons

  • Type and origin not stated in the title
  • More than a single batch needs

4. Spicy Organic Whole Cloves, 4 oz: USDA Organic Ceylon clove buds, kosher

Best cloves

Spicy Organic Whole Cloves, 4 oz

Cloves give mulled drinks their deep, slightly sharp warmth. Spicy Organic's whole cloves state USDA Organic, Ceylon clove buds and kosher in the listing title. The listing has more than 500 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.7 stars, and the 4 oz size is among the better-selling organic cloves on Amazon.

Cloves are strong, so a teaspoon is enough for a gallon of cider. The classic trick is to stud an orange with them, which looks festive and makes the cloves easy to remove. Our guide to the best organic whole cloves compares more options.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic and kosher
  • Names Ceylon as the source
  • 4 oz lasts through the holidays and beyond
  • Also used for ham, baking and chai

Key specifications

TypeWhole clove buds
Net weight4 oz
OriginCeylon (listing)
CertificationUSDA Organic, kosher (listing)
Other sizes1 lb

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want certified organic cloves for mulling, baking and holiday cooking.

Skip it if you only need a small jar for one batch.

Pros

  • Clear certification claims
  • Stated origin
  • Well rated

Cons

  • Fewer reviews than the biggest sellers
  • Packaging type not stated in the title

5. The Spice Way Star Anise, 3 oz: A light licorice note and a beautiful garnish

Best star anise

The Spice Way Star Anise, 3 oz

Star anise is the star-shaped pod you see floating in photos of mulled wine. It adds a gentle licorice sweetness and looks striking in a pot or a mug. The Spice Way's whole star anise has more than 7,000 reviews with a rating of about 4.6 stars.

Use two or three pods for a pot. Star anise is strong, and too much can take over. Whole, unbroken stars look best as a garnish, and some broken pieces in a bag are normal.

Why we like it

  • Very large review base
  • Adds flavor and a festive look
  • 3 oz covers many batches
  • Also used in pho, braises and baking

Key specifications

TypeWhole star anise
Net weight3 oz
UseBaking and tea (listing)
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want the classic look and a subtle licorice note in mulled wine or cider.

Skip it if you dislike licorice flavors. Leave it out and the drink will still be good.

Pros

  • Attractive garnish
  • Strong seller
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Some pods may arrive broken
  • Not labeled organic

6. Spicy World Whole Allspice Berries, 2 oz: The spice that rounds everything out

Best allspice

Spicy World Whole Allspice Berries, 2 oz

Allspice berries taste like a mix of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, which makes them a natural fit for mulling. Spicy World's whole berries have more than 1,000 reviews with a rating of about 4.8 stars.

The 2 oz bag is the right size for most kitchens. You will use about a teaspoon of berries per gallon. Larger bags from the same brand are available as separate listings.

Why we like it

  • Very high rating
  • Small bag suits how little you use
  • Whole berries keep for years
  • Also used in pickling, brines and jerk seasoning

Key specifications

TypeWhole allspice berries
Net weight2 oz (57 g)
ClaimsNatural, vegan (listing)
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you are mixing your own mulling spices and want a full, rounded flavor.

Skip it if you want the simplest blend. Cinnamon and cloves alone will do.

Pros

  • Well rated
  • Right-sized
  • Multi-purpose

Cons

  • Not labeled organic
  • Optional in simple recipes

7. HANDPICK Green Cardamom Pods, 2 oz: An optional lift for a brighter cup

Best optional extra

HANDPICK Green Cardamom Pods, 2 oz

Cardamom is not in every mulling blend, but a few lightly crushed pods add a bright, floral note that works well with apple and orange. It is traditional in Scandinavian mulled wine. HANDPICK's green cardamom pods have more than 10,000 reviews with a rating of about 4.4 stars.

Crush four or five pods with the flat of a knife so the seeds can release their flavor. Our guide to the best cardamom pods covers more options.

Why we like it

  • Very large review base
  • Adds a fresh, floral note
  • Small pack is enough for a season
  • Also used in chai, coffee and baking

Key specifications

TypeGreen cardamom pods
Net weight2 oz
ClaimsNon-GMO (listing)
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want your mulled drink to taste a little different from the standard blend.

Skip it if you prefer the classic cinnamon and clove flavor on its own.

Pros

  • Distinctive flavor
  • Many reviews
  • Versatile

Cons

  • Rated a little lower than other picks
  • Optional

How to choose and use mulling spices

1. Ready-made or mix your own

A ready-made mix or spice bag is the fastest way to a mug of mulled cider. Mixing your own from whole spices costs more to start, but the flavor is fresher and brighter, you control the balance, and the same spices are useful in baking and cooking all winter.

2. Always use whole spices

Ground spices make a mulled drink cloudy and gritty and can turn bitter with long heating. Whole spices release their flavor slowly and are easy to strain out. If you only have ground spices, tie them in a coffee filter or use a tea infuser.

3. A ratio for a gallon of cider

A good starting point is 4 cinnamon sticks, 1 teaspoon whole cloves, 1 teaspoon allspice berries, 2 or 3 star anise and the peel of one orange. For a bottle of red wine, halve the spices and add 2 to 4 tablespoons of sugar or honey to taste.

4. Heat gently

Warm the drink over low heat and keep it below a boil. For cider, 20 to 30 minutes is enough, and it can sit on low for a couple of hours. For wine, keep it just steaming, since boiling drives off the alcohol and makes the wine taste harsh.

5. Do not over-steep

Cloves and star anise get stronger the longer they sit. If the pot will be out for hours, lift the spices out once the flavor is where you like it. A spice bag, tea ball or square of cheesecloth makes this easy.

6. Storage

Whole spices keep their aroma for two to three years in airtight containers away from heat and light. Our guide to storing spices has more detail.

How we chose these mulling spices

We started with the spices that classic mulled cider and mulled wine recipes call for, then looked at Amazon's best sellers in each one using estimated sales, review counts and ratings from marketplace data. We kept products rated 4.4 stars or higher and chose pack sizes that suit home use.

Amazon's product pages could not be read by our tools, so details come from listing titles and are labeled that way. Where we could not confirm something, such as a mix's full ingredients, we say so. We have not tasted these side by side, so this is a research-based comparison and not a taste test.

How to make mulled cider

This makes about 16 small cups and scales up or down easily.

  1. Pour 1 gallon of apple cider into a large pot or slow cooker.
  2. Add 4 cinnamon sticks, 1 teaspoon whole cloves, 1 teaspoon allspice berries and 2 or 3 star anise. Add strips of orange peel if you like.
  3. Warm over low heat for 20 to 30 minutes. Do not let it boil.
  4. Taste, and add a little brown sugar or maple syrup only if the cider needs it.
  5. Strain or lift out the spices, and serve warm with a cinnamon stick in each mug.

For mulled wine, use one bottle of red wine, half the spices and sugar or honey to taste, and keep it just below a simmer.

Leftover mulled cider keeps in the fridge for a few days and reheats well.

Frequently asked questions

What are mulling spices made of?

Usually cinnamon sticks, whole cloves and allspice berries, often with star anise and dried orange peel. Some blends add cardamom, ginger or nutmeg.

How much mulling spice do I need for a gallon of cider?

About 4 cinnamon sticks, 1 teaspoon whole cloves, 1 teaspoon allspice berries and 2 or 3 star anise. With a ready-made mix, follow the package directions.

Can I use ground spices for mulling?

Whole spices are better. Ground spices make the drink cloudy and gritty. If ground is all you have, tie it in a coffee filter or use a tea infuser.

Can I use the same spices for cider and wine?

Yes. Use about half as much for a bottle of wine as for a gallon of cider, and sweeten the wine to taste.

How long should mulling spices steep?

About 20 to 30 minutes over low heat. Remove the spices if the pot will sit for hours, so cloves and star anise do not take over.

Can I reuse mulling spices?

They can be used a second time the same day with a weaker result. For the best flavor, start with fresh spices for each batch.

Do mulling spices go bad?

Whole spices do not spoil but lose aroma over time. They are at their best within two to three years, stored airtight away from heat.

Our final pick

For the easiest mug, buy Aspen Mulling Cider Spices or the tidy Olde Tradition tea bags. To mix your own, stock McCormick Cinnamon Sticks, Spicy Organic Whole Cloves, The Spice Way Star Anise and Spicy World Allspice Berries.

Planning the rest of the holiday table? See our guides to the best spices for pumpkin pie, best organic whole cloves and best gifts for home cooks, and the rest of our buying guides.