Independent picks. We may earn a commission when you buy through our links — how it works

Holiday Baking

Best Spices for Pumpkin Pie: 7 Top Picks, Blends and Single Spices

A bowl of pumpkin pie spice on a wooden table with cinnamon sticks, cloves, nutmeg, allspice, small pumpkins and a slice of pumpkin pie with whipped cream

Pumpkin on its own is mild and a little earthy. What people think of as the taste of pumpkin pie is really the spice: cinnamon first, then ginger, nutmeg, cloves and often allspice. Get those right and even a simple pie from canned pumpkin tastes like the holidays.

You have two ways to get there. A jar of pumpkin pie spice is a ready-made blend that takes one measuring spoon. Buying the single spices costs more up front but lets you adjust the balance, and you will use each of them all winter in cookies, cider, oatmeal and coffee. This guide covers both, with seven top-selling picks and a ratio for mixing your own.

Our top picks at a glance

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no extra cost to you. Products were chosen using Amazon sales rank and review data. One brand in this guide is affiliated with us. Details come from listing titles and may change, so confirm them on the listing before you buy. How we choose.

Quick verdict

If you bake one or two pies a year, buy a blend. McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice is the classic small jar, and Frontier Co-op Pumpkin Pie Spice is the best-selling blend we found. Either one gives you a balanced pie with no measuring of separate spices.

If you bake often, build the set: McCormick Ground Cinnamon as the base, Spicy Organic Ground Ginger for warmth, Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg for the sweet, nutty note, Simply Organic Whole Cloves to grind fresh, and McCormick Ground Allspice to round it out.

At a glance

Two blends first, then the five single spices in the order most recipes use them. Pack size is as stated in each Amazon listing title.

ProductBest forWhat it isPack sizeRole in the pieWhere to buy
McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.12 ozBest ready-made blendEasiest optionReady-made blend1.12 ozAll the spice in one jarCheck price on Amazon
Frontier Co-op Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.72 ozBest-selling blendBest-selling blendReady-made blend1.72 ozAll the spice in one jarCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 ozBest cinnamonThe base spiceGround cinnamon7.12 ozSweet, warm backboneCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Ground Ginger Powder, 4 ozBest gingerWarmth and biteGround ginger4 ozGentle heatCheck price on Amazon
Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 ozBest nutmegSweet, nutty depthGround nutmeg4 ozRound, nutty sweetnessCheck price on Amazon
Simply Organic Whole Cloves, 2.05 ozBest clovesGrinding freshWhole cloves2.05 ozDeep, sharp accentCheck price on Amazon
McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 ozBest allspiceRounding out the blendGround allspice0.9 ozPeppery, clove-like warmthCheck price on Amazon

Pack sizes and claims are quoted from listing titles and could not be checked against the package. Blend ingredients vary by brand, so check the label if you avoid a particular spice.

Our 7 best spices for pumpkin pie

The first two picks are blends and the other five are single spices. Each is a top seller or a well-rated option in its category. We have not baked with them side by side, so this guide compares what each listing states along with sales and review data.

1. McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.12 oz: The classic jar for one or two pies

Best ready-made blend

McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.12 oz

McCormick's pumpkin pie spice is the jar many families already reach for in November. It has more than 8,000 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.8 stars at the time we checked.

The 1.12 oz jar holds enough for several pies, which is right for most households, because a ground blend is at its best in its first year. If you bake for a crowd, the same blend comes in a 9 oz size as a separate listing.

Why we like it

  • Familiar, balanced flavor
  • One spoonful replaces four or five jars
  • Very high rating with thousands of reviews
  • Small jar stays fresh

Key specifications

TypePumpkin pie spice blend
Net weight1.12 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated
Other sizes9 oz (separate listing)

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you bake a pie or two each year and want the simplest route.

Skip it if you like to adjust the balance yourself, or you want an organic blend.

Pros

  • Easy
  • Consistent
  • Well reviewed
  • Right-sized

Cons

  • Fixed balance of spices
  • Not labeled organic
  • Ingredients not listed in the title

2. Frontier Co-op Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.72 oz: The best-selling blend this season

Best-selling blend

Frontier Co-op Pumpkin Pie Spice, 1.72 oz

Frontier Co-op's pumpkin pie spice was the best-selling pumpkin pie spice blend we found on Amazon when we checked, with several hundred reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars.

At 1.72 oz it gives you a little more than the standard small jar, which is useful if you also stir the blend into coffee, oatmeal or quick breads through the season. Frontier also sells an organic version in a 16 oz bulk bag as a separate listing.

Why we like it

  • Top seller among blends
  • A bit more than the usual small jar
  • Very high rating
  • Organic bulk version available separately

Key specifications

TypePumpkin pie spice blend
Net weight1.72 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated for this size
Other optionOrganic 16 oz bag (separate listing)

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want a blend and plan to use it in more than just pie.

Skip it if you want a blend with thousands of reviews behind it.

Pros

  • Strong seller
  • High rating
  • Generous small jar

Cons

  • Fewer reviews than McCormick
  • Organic not stated for this size
  • Ingredients not listed in the title

3. McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 oz: The backbone of the blend

Best cinnamon

McCormick Ground Cinnamon, 7.12 oz

Cinnamon makes up more than half of most pumpkin pie spice. McCormick Ground Cinnamon is the top-selling ground cinnamon we found, with more than 11,000 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars. It has the bold, sweet flavor American baking recipes are written for.

The 7.12 oz jar is far more than a pie needs, but cinnamon is the one spice in this set you will use every week. Our guide to Ceylon vs. cassia cinnamon explains the two types if you want a milder option.

Why we like it

  • Top seller with a very high rating
  • Bold flavor that holds up to baking
  • Shaker jar
  • Useful all year

Key specifications

TypeGround cinnamon (type not stated in the title)
Net weight7.12 oz
PackagingShaker jar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want a dependable cinnamon for pie, rolls, toast and oatmeal.

Skip it if you prefer the softer taste of Ceylon cinnamon or want organic.

Pros

  • Trusted brand
  • Strong flavor
  • Good size for regular bakers

Cons

  • Type and origin not stated in the title
  • Not labeled organic

4. Spicy Organic Ground Ginger Powder, 4 oz: USDA Organic ginger in a baking-friendly size

Best ginger

Spicy Organic Ground Ginger Powder, 4 oz

Ginger gives pumpkin pie its gentle warmth and keeps the filling from tasting flat. Spicy Organic's ground ginger states USDA Organic in the listing title and is made from dried ginger root. The listing has close to 400 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.6 stars.

Many top-selling ginger powders come by the pound. The 4 oz size is a better fit for holiday baking, with enough for pies, gingerbread and ginger cookies. Larger 8 oz and 16 oz sizes are in the same listing.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic
  • 4 oz suits a season of baking
  • Works in pie, gingerbread and cookies
  • Larger sizes in the same listing

Key specifications

TypeGround ginger
Net weight4 oz
CertificationUSDA Organic (listing)
Made fromDried ginger root (listing)
Other sizes8 oz, 16 oz

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic ginger in an amount you will finish while it is fresh.

Skip it if you use ginger daily in large amounts. A 1 lb bag costs less per ounce.

Pros

  • Organic certification claim
  • Sensible size
  • Well rated

Cons

  • Fewer reviews than the biggest sellers
  • Origin not stated in the title

5. Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 oz: USDA Organic nutmeg, kosher

Best nutmeg

Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg Powder, 4 oz

Nutmeg adds the sweet, nutty note that makes a custard pie taste rich. Spicy Organic's ground nutmeg states USDA Organic and kosher in the listing title, and has more than 100 reviews across its sizes with a rating of about 4.7 stars.

Supermarket nutmeg usually comes in jars of about an ounce. Four ounces is plenty for pies, eggnog, custards, cream sauces and mashed potatoes through the winter. Use a light hand, because nutmeg is strong.

Why we like it

  • States USDA Organic and kosher
  • More than a standard small jar
  • Useful in sweet and savory cooking
  • Larger sizes in the same listing

Key specifications

TypeGround nutmeg
Net weight4 oz
CertificationUSDA Organic, kosher (listing)
Other sizes8 oz, 1 lb
OriginNot stated in the title for this size

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you want organic nutmeg and will use it beyond one pie.

Skip it if you only need a pinch a year. A 1 oz jar is enough.

Pros

  • Organic and kosher claims
  • Good rating
  • Useful size for holiday cooking

Cons

  • Smaller review count
  • More than a once-a-year baker needs

6. Simply Organic Whole Cloves, 2.05 oz: Grind a few fresh for the strongest flavor

Best cloves

Simply Organic Whole Cloves, 2.05 oz

Cloves are the most powerful spice in the blend, and a small amount is enough. Simply Organic's whole cloves come in a glass jar and have more than 19,000 reviews with a rating of about 4.8 stars.

These are whole cloves, so you will need to grind them in a spice grinder or mortar before they go into pie filling. The reward is a brighter flavor than pre-ground cloves, and whole cloves keep for years. Our guide to the best organic whole cloves covers more options.

Why we like it

  • Very large review base and a high rating
  • Whole cloves keep their aroma for years
  • Glass jar fits a spice rack
  • Also useful for ham, cider and chai

Key specifications

TypeWhole cloves
Net weight2.05 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicYes (brand and listing)

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you own a spice grinder or mortar and want the freshest clove flavor.

Skip it if you want something ready to measure. Buy ground cloves or use a blend.

Pros

  • Long shelf life
  • Trusted organic brand
  • Multi-purpose

Cons

  • Needs grinding for pie
  • Small jar

7. McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 oz: The spice that ties the others together

Best allspice

McCormick Ground Allspice, 0.9 oz

Allspice is a single dried berry that tastes like a mix of cinnamon, nutmeg and cloves, which is how it got its name. Many pumpkin pie spice blends include it to round out the flavor. McCormick Ground Allspice is the top seller we found, with more than 1,200 reviews and a rating of about 4.8 stars.

The 0.9 oz jar is small, and that is the right amount. You will use a quarter to half a teaspoon at a time.

Why we like it

  • Top-selling ground allspice
  • Small jar suits how little you use
  • Very high rating
  • Adds depth to pies, cakes and jerk seasoning

Key specifications

TypeGround allspice
Net weight0.9 oz
PackagingJar
OrganicNot stated

Why we recommend it

Choose it if you are mixing your own pumpkin pie spice and want the full, rounded flavor.

Skip it if you prefer a simpler blend. Many recipes leave allspice out.

Pros

  • Right-sized
  • Well rated
  • Widely available

Cons

  • Not labeled organic
  • Optional in many recipes

How to choose spices for pumpkin pie

1. Blend or single spices

A blend is the easy choice if you bake one or two pies a year. Buying the single spices makes sense if you bake often, want to adjust the balance, or already own two or three of them. You can also do both: use a blend and add extra cinnamon or ginger to taste.

2. What each spice does

Cinnamon is the sweet, warm base and makes up most of the blend. Ginger adds a gentle heat. Nutmeg brings a round, nutty sweetness that suits custard. Cloves are sharp and deep, and a little goes a long way. Allspice sits between them and smooths the mix. Some bakers add a pinch of black pepper or cardamom for interest.

3. A ratio for mixing your own

A common starting point is 3 tablespoons ground cinnamon, 2 teaspoons ground ginger, 2 teaspoons ground nutmeg, 1 teaspoon ground allspice and 1 teaspoon ground cloves. Stir well and store in a small jar. This makes about a quarter cup. Use roughly 2 teaspoons for a standard 9 inch pie, or follow your recipe.

4. Freshness matters most

Ground spices fade. A jar that has been open for three years will make a dull pie no matter the brand. Smell each spice before you bake. If the aroma is faint, replace it or use a little more. Buy small amounts of the spices you use rarely, such as cloves and allspice.

5. Whole or ground

Whole nutmeg and whole cloves keep their flavor for years and taste brighter when freshly grated or ground. If you have a fine grater or a spice grinder, they are worth it. Otherwise ground spices are fine for pie, as long as they are fresh.

6. Organic and other claims

If organic matters to you, look for the USDA Organic seal or the words certified organic on the pack. We quote claims from listing titles and could not check certificates, so confirm on the listing. Our guide to storing spices explains how to keep them fresh.

How we chose these spices

We started with the spices that classic pumpkin pie recipes call for, then looked at Amazon's best sellers in each one using estimated sales, review counts and ratings from marketplace data. We kept products rated 4.6 stars or higher and chose pack sizes that suit home baking, which means we sometimes picked a smaller size over the single biggest seller.

Amazon's product pages could not be read by our tools, so details come from listing titles and are labeled that way. Where we could not confirm something, such as a blend's ingredients or an origin, we say so. We have not baked with these side by side, so this is a research-based comparison and not a taste test.

How to spice a pumpkin pie

These steps work with a blend or with single spices.

  1. Check your spices. Smell each jar and replace any that have lost their aroma.
  2. Measure about 2 teaspoons of pumpkin pie spice for a 9 inch pie, or the amounts your recipe gives for each spice.
  3. Whisk the spices into the sugar first, then add the pumpkin. This spreads them evenly and prevents clumps.
  4. Taste the filling before adding raw eggs. Adjust with a pinch more cinnamon or ginger if you want it bolder.
  5. Bake as your recipe directs, and let the pie cool fully. The spice flavor deepens as it rests.

Add cloves and nutmeg carefully. Too much of either can taste bitter or medicinal.

Leftover blend is good in whipped cream, coffee, oatmeal, pancakes and roasted squash.

Frequently asked questions

What spices are in pumpkin pie?

Cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and cloves are the core four, and many recipes add allspice. Cinnamon makes up the largest share.

What is pumpkin pie spice made of?

It is a blend of ground cinnamon, ginger, nutmeg and cloves, often with allspice. The exact mix varies by brand, so check the label.

How much pumpkin pie spice goes in one pie?

About 2 teaspoons for a standard 9 inch pie is a common amount. Follow your recipe, and add a little more if your spices are older.

Can I make my own pumpkin pie spice?

Yes. Mix 3 tablespoons cinnamon, 2 teaspoons ginger, 2 teaspoons nutmeg, 1 teaspoon allspice and 1 teaspoon cloves. Store it in an airtight jar.

Is pumpkin pie spice the same as allspice?

No. Allspice is a single dried berry. Pumpkin pie spice is a blend of several spices, and allspice is sometimes one of them.

What can I use if I have no pumpkin pie spice?

Use cinnamon with smaller amounts of ginger and nutmeg, and a pinch of cloves if you have it. Even cinnamon and ginger alone make a good pie.

How long does pumpkin pie spice last?

It is best within about a year of opening. It stays safe to use after that but loses strength, so you may need a little more.

Our final pick

For the simplest pie, buy McCormick Pumpkin Pie Spice or the best-selling Frontier Co-op blend. To mix your own, start with McCormick Ground Cinnamon, Spicy Organic Ground Ginger and Spicy Organic Ground Nutmeg, then add freshly ground cloves and a little allspice.

Getting ready for the holidays? See our guides to the best turkey roasting pans, best meat thermometers and best kitchen scales, and the rest of our buying guides.